By Charles Parker, MD
2008-05-01
Dr. Parker has indicated no relevant conflicts of interest.
Dr. Parker is Professor of Medicine in the Division of Hematology and
Bone Marrow Transplant at the University of Utah School of Medicine.
Introduction
Paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH) is a consequence of clonal
expansion of one or more hematopoietic stem cells with mutant PIGA
(located on Xp22.1).1 The protein product of PIGA is a
glycosyl transferase that is an obligate constituent of a complex multiprotein
pathway required for synthesis of the glycosyl phosphatidylinositol (GPI)
moiety that anchors some proteins to the cell surface. As a result of mutant PIGA,
progeny of the affected stem cells are deficient in all GPI-anchored proteins
(GPI-AP). Although more than 20 functionally diverse GPI-APs are expressed by
hematopoietic cells, it is deficiency on RBCs of the two GPI-anchored
complement regulatory proteins, CD55 (decay accelerating factor) and CD59
(membrane inhibitor of reactive lysis), that underlies the hemolytic anemia
that is the clinical hallmark of PNH. RBCs lacking CD55 and CD59 undergo
spontaneous intravascular hemolysis as a consequence of unregulated activation
of the alternative pathway of complement.
The peripheral blood of patients with PNH is a mosaic of normal and
abnormal cells
Although PNH is a clonal disease, it is not a malignant disease, and (for
reasons that are unclear) the extent to which the PIGA mutant clone expands
varies widely among patients. As an example, in some cases, >90 percent of
the peripheral blood cells may be derived from the mutant clone, while in
others, <10 percent of the circulating cells may be GPI-AP deficient.
Another remarkable feature of PNH is phenotypic mosaicism based on PIGA
genotype that determines the degree of GPI-AP deficiency.2 PNH III
cells are completely deficient in GPI-APs, PNH II cells are partially (~90
percent) deficient, and PNH I cells express GPI-APs at normal density (these
cells are progeny of residual normal stem cells). Phenotype varies among
patients (see Figure 1). Some patients have only type I and type III cells (the
most common phenotype); some have type I, type II, and type III (the second
most common phenotype); and some patients have only type I and type II cells
(the least common phenotype). Further, the contribution of each phenotype to
the composition of the peripheral blood varies (see F.1). Phenotypic mosaicism
is clinically relevant because PNH II cells are relatively resistant to spontaneous
hemolysis, and patients with a high percentage of type II cells have a
relatively benign clinical course (see F.1).
Table: Classification of PNH*
|
Category
|
Rate of Intravascular Hemolysis**
|
Bone Marrow
|
Flow Cytometry
|
Benefit from Eculizumab
|
Classic
|
Florid (macroscopic hemoglobinuria is frequent or
persistent)
|
Cellular marrow with erythroid hyperplasia and normal or
near-normal morphology†
|
Large population (>50%) of GPI-AP deficient PMNs¶
|
Yes
|
PNH in the setting of another bone marrow failure
syndrome§
|
Mild to moderate (macroscopic hemoglobinuria is
intermittent or absent)
|
Evidence of a concomitant bone marrow failure syndrome§
|
Although variable, the percentage of GPI-AP deficient
PMNs¶ is usually relatively small (<30%)
|
Dependent on the size of the PNH clone
|
Subclinical
|
No clinical or biochemical evidence of intravascular
hemolysis
|
Evidence of a concomitant bone marrow failure syndrome§
|
Small (<1%) population of GPI-AP deficient PMNs
detected by high-resolution flow cytometry
|
No
|
* Based on recommendations of the Int'l PNH Interest Group4
** Based on macroscopic hemoglobinuria, serum LDH concentration, and
reticulocyte count
† Karyotypic abnormalities are uncommon.
§ Aplastic anemia and refractory anemia/MDS are the most commonly associated
marrow failure syndromes.
¶ Analysis of PMNs is more informative than analysis of RBCs due to selective
destruction GPI-AP deficient RBCs.
|
The anemia of PNH is complex
The anemia of PNH is complex for three reasons. First, the size of the PNH
clone varies widely among patients (see F.1 & 2). Patients with large PNH
clones (see F.2, upper panel) have classic signs and symptoms of PNH (see
Table) while patients with small clones (see F.2, lower panel) may have only
biochemical evidence of hemolysis with minimal or no clinical manifestations
(see Table). Second, PNH phenotype affects the rate of hemolysis, as PNH II
RBCs are significantly more resistant to complement-mediated injury than PNH
III RBCs (see F.1). Third, an element of bone marrow failure is present in all
patients with PNH, although the degree of marrow dysfunction is variable. In
some patients, PNH arises in the setting of aplastic anemia. In this case,
marrow failure is the dominant cause of anemia. In other patients, evidence of
marrow dysfunction may be subtle (e.g., an inappropriately low reticulocyte
count) with the degree of anemia being determined primarily by the rate of
hemolysis.
Diagnosis
The primary clinical manifestations of PNH are hemolysis, thrombosis, and
bone marrow failure. Constitutional symptoms (fatigue, lethargy, malaise, and
asthenia) dominate the history, but nocturnal hemoglobinuria is a presenting
symptom in only about 25 percent of patients. Directed questioning frequently
elicits a history of episodic dysphagia and odynophagia, abdominal pain, and
male impotence. PNH should be suspected in patients with non-spherocytic,
Coombs'-negative intravascular hemolysis. Reticulocytosis reflects the response
to hemolysis, although the reticulocyte count may be lower than expected for
the degree of anemia because of underlying bone marrow failure. Serum LDH
concentration is always abnormally high in patients with clinically significant
hemolysis and serves as a valuable surrogate marker for determining and
following the rate of intravascular hemolysis. Most patients are iron-deficient
because of chronic hemoglobinuria and hemosiderinuria (even in the absence of
gross hemoglobinuria). Venous thrombosis, often occurring at unusual sites
(Budd-Chiari syndrome; mesenteric, dermal, or cerebral veins), may complicate
PNH. Arterial thrombosis is less common. Varying degrees of leukopenia,
thrombocytopenia, and relative reticulocytopenia reflect the extent of marrow
insufficiency.
Once suspected, diagnosing PNH is straightforward as deficiency of GPI-APs
on peripheral blood cells is readily demonstrated by flow cytometry (see F.2).
Analysis of both RBCs and PMNs is warranted, as clone size will be underestimated
if only RBCs are examined (see F.2) because type III red cells are rapidly
destroyed by complement. Recent transfusion will also affect the estimate of
clone size if only RBCs are analyzed, but PNH phenotype is best determined by
analysis of RBCs (see F.1). For accurate quantitation of GPI-AP expression on
PMNs, samples should be analyzed within 24 to 48 hours of collection, whereas
the window for analysis of RBCs is two weeks if samples are properly stored.
Analysis of GPI-AP expression on lymphocytes provides no additional useful
clinical information. Using high-resolution techniques available in some
laboratories, as few as 0.003 percent GPI-AP deficient RBCs and PMNs can be
detected (see F.2, lower panel). High-resolution flow cytometry is most useful
in analyzing samples from patients with aplastic anemia or refractory
anemia/MDS who may have very small clones, as some studies suggest that the
presence of a small PNH clone predicts both a favorable prognosis and a higher
rate of response to immunosuppressive therapy.3
Bone marrow analysis is warranted to determine cellularity, morphology, and
iron stores. Non-random cytogenetic abnormalities are uncommon in PNH, but
karyotyping may be informative if myelodysplasia is suspected. Flow-cytometric
analysis of GPI-AP expression on bone marrow cells has no clinical utility.
Based on the results of laboratory studies, bone marrow analysis, and flow
cytometry, patients can be placed into one of three categories based on the
recommendation of the International PNH Interest Group4 (see Table).
Management
Hemolysis. The approval of eculizumab by the FDA had a great impact
on the management of PNH. Eculizumab is a humanized monoclonal antibody that
blocks formation of the membrane attack complex (the cytolytic component of the
complement system) by binding to complement C5.5 The drug is given
as an intravenous infusion (on an every-other-week schedule after an initial
five-week loading period), and it is a highly efficacious inhibitor of
complement-mediated intravascular hemolysis. Treatment with eculizumab reduces
transfusion requirements, ameliorates the anemia, and markedly improves quality
of life by resolving the debilitating constitutional symptoms associated with
chronic complement-mediated intravascular hemolysis.6 Treatment is
generally well tolerated, but patients are at risk for neisserial infections,
and vaccination against N. menigitidis is required prior to initiating
therapy. Vaccine protection is incomplete, however, as episodes of
meningococcal sepsis have been reported. Following treatment, serum LDH
concentration returns to normal, but mild to moderate anemia and
reticulocytosis usually persist, likely the result of ongoing extravascular
hemolysis mediated by opsoinization of PNH RBCs by activated complement C3
(eculizumab does not block the formation of the alternative pathway C3
convertase). By protecting RBCs against complement-mediated lysis, the
percentage of PNH cells in the peripheral blood increases in patients being
treated with eculizumab, but concerns about precipitating a catastrophic
hemolytic crisis if the drug is abruptly discontinued appear unfounded.6,7
Eculizumab is expensive (nearly $400,000/year), and it has no effect on the
underlying stem cell abnormality, meaning that treatment will likely continue
indefinitely. Because the clinical manifestations of PNH vary widely among
patients, not all are appropriate candidates for treatment with eculizumab.
Prior to recommending eculizumab therapy, PNH clone size (based on flow
cytometric analysis of GPI-AP expression on PMNs), rate of hemolysis (based on
serum LDH concentration), and degree of bone marrow failure (based on blood
counts, reticulocytosis, and bone marrow cellularity and morphology) should be
determined. Patients who are likely to benefit most from treatment are those
with large clones whose clinical manifestations are primarily a consequence of
intravascular hemolysis (Classic PNH, see Table). Patients with relatively
small clones whose primary clinical manifestations are a consequence of bone
marrow failure (PNH in the setting of bone marrow failure, see Table) are
unlikely to benefit from eculizumab. For those patients, treatment should focus
on the process that underlies the bone marrow failure. Eculizumab has no role
in the management of Subclinical PNH, and, in those cases, treatment should be
aimed at the marrow failure process.
The use of steroids (glucocorticoids and androgens) in the management of PNH
is controversial.4 Corticosteroids can be used to mitigate a hemolytic
paroxysm, but long-term use is not recommended because of unacceptable
toxicity. In my experience, hemolysis is ameliorated in about one-third of
patients with Classic PNH treated with danazol, a generally well-tolerated
synthetic androgen that does not cause masculinization. Danazol may have the
added benefit of providing benefit for the hypoproliferative component of the
disease. Patients should be iron replete before initiating therapy with
danazol, and liver function should be monitored regularly. General supportive
measures include repletion of iron stores and folate supplementation. Red cell
transfusion is safe and may be necessary for treatment of inadequately
compensated anemia.
Thrombosis. The mechanism that accounts for the thrombotic risk in
PNH is unknown, but thromboembolic complications (often involving unusual
sites) are the leading cause of morbidity and mortality in PNH. Available data
suggest that PNH clone size is the major risk factor for thrombosis,8,9 although
geographical location and ethnicity may influence the rate of risk.4
Warfarin prophylaxis is recommended for patients with Classic PNH, and patients
who experience a thrombotic episode should be anticoagulated indefinitely.
Treatment with eculizumab may reduce the risk of thrombosis,10 and
patients treated with eculizumab may not require warfarin prophylaxis. However,
data are insufficient to support discontinuation of anticoagulation therapy in
a patient who experiences a thromboembolic complication prior to initiating
therapy with eculizumab. Thrombolytic therapy should be considered in a patient
who develops Budd-Chiari syndrome acutely.4
Bone marrow failure. Treatment of anemia that is primarily due to
bone marrow failure should be aimed at the underlying disease (e.g., aplastic
anemia, refractory anemia/MDS). If absolute or relative erythropoietin
deficiency is felt to contribute to the anemia, replacement with the
recombinant protein is warranted, but patients should be closely monitored as
erythropoietin supplementation may exacerbate hemolysis by increasing
production of GPI-AP deficient RBCs.
Bone marrow transplantation. Prior to the availability of
eculizumab, the primary indications for transplant were recurrent,
life-threatening thrombosis and uncontrollable hemolysis. The latter process
can be eliminated by treatment with eculizumab, and the former process may also
respond to inhibition of intravascular hemolysis.10 Nonetheless,
transplant is the only curative therapy for PNH, and the availability of
matched unrelated donors, less toxic conditioning regimens, reduction in
transplant-related morbidity and mortality, and improvements in post-transplant
supportive care make this option increasingly attractive. The decision about
transplant is complex, however, and requires input from the patient, an
experienced hematologist, and a transplant specialist.
Pregnancy. There are both maternal and fetal risks when PNH occurs
during pregnancy with the risk primarily being due to thromboembolic
complications.4 Untoward events can be expected in at least half of
the mothers and in some of the neonates. Counseling female patients with PNH
about pregnancy should take into account age, overall health, PNH clone size
and phenotype, extent of hemolysis, degree of bone marrow failure (especially
thrombocytopenia), previous thrombosis, and comorbid conditions. Despite the
many concerns, successful outcomes appear to be the rule rather than the
exception. But management is complicated and should involve the combined
efforts of an experienced hematologist and an obstetrician specializing in
high-risk pregnancy. Unless there is an absolute contraindication,
anticoagulation with heparin (preferably low-molecular-weight heparin) should
be initiated as soon as pregnancy is documented and continued until immediately
prior to delivery. Heparin should be reinstituted post-delivery as soon as
treatment is safe, and prophylaxis with warfarin is recommended for three
months after parturition.
Eculizumab is not approved for use in patients who are pregnant. If a
patient becomes pregnant while being treated with eculizumab, the drug should
be discontinued and prophylactic anticoagulation with heparin should be
initiated. Treatment with eculizumab can be restarted in the immediate
postpartum period. Whether treatment with eculizumab obviates the need for
prophylactic anticoagulation in the postpartum period if the patient has no
antecedent history of thromboembolic complications is unknown. Lacking data to
the contrary, prophylactic anticoagulation during the postpartum period is
recommended for these patients.
Summary
Eculizumab has changed the natural history and management of PNH. But PNH is
not a binary disease, and not every patient who has a PNH clone is an
appropriate candidate for treatment. In particular, patients with small clones
whose primary clinical manifestations are a consequence of bone marrow failure
are unlikely to benefit. Appropriate disease classification (see Table) based
on clone size, underlying bone marrow pathology, and rate of hemolysis, along
with an understanding of the pathophysiology of the anemia and the
heterogeneous nature of the disease, are needed in order to make a rational
decision about management.
References
- Parker CJ. The
pathophysiology of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Exp Hematol.
2007;35:523-33.
- Endo M, Ware RE, Vreeke TM,
et al. Molecular
basis of the heterogeneity of expression of glycosyl phosphatidylinositol
anchored proteins in paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Blood.
1996;87:2546-57.
- Sugimori C, Chuhjo T, Feng
X, et al. Minor
population of CD55-CD59-blood cells predicts response to immunosuppressive
therapy and prognosis in patients with aplastic anemia. Blood.
2006;107:1308-14.
- Parker C, Omine M, Richards
S, et al. Diagnosis
and management of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Blood.
2005;106:3699-709.
- Rother RP, Rollins SA,
Mojcik CF, et al. Discovery and development of the complement inhibitor
eculizumab for the treatment of paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Nat
Biotechnol. 2007;25:1256-64.
- Hillmen P, Young NS,
Schubert J, et al. The complement inhibitor eculizumab in paroxysmal
nocturnal hemoglobinuria. N Engl J Med. 2006;355:1233-43.
- Brodsky RA, Young NS,
Antonioli E, et al.
Multicenter
phase 3 study of the complement inhibitor eculizumab for the treatment of
patients with paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Blood.
2008;111:1840-47.
- Hall C, Richards S, Hillmen
P.
Primary prophylaxis with warfarin prevents thrombosis in paroxysmal
nocturnal hemoglobinuria (PNH). Blood. 2003;102:3587-91.
- Moyo VM, Mukhina GL,
Garrett ES, et al. Natural history of paroxysmal nocturnal haemoglobinuria
using modern diagnostic assays. Br J Haematol. 2004;126:133-8.
- Hillmen P, Muus P, Dührsen
U, et al. Effect
of the complement inhibitor eculizumab on thromboembolism in patients with
paroxysmal nocturnal hemoglobinuria. Blood. 2007;110:4123-28.
back to top